We hope you love the products we recommend! Just so you know, Trendy Mami may collect a share of sales or other compensations from the links on this page.
–
Jewelry can look beautiful online and feel completely different once you actually have it in your hands. The sparkle, size, details, and way a piece looks with an outfit matter just as much as the product photos, especially when you’re spending hundreds of dollars. For this Brilliant Earth jewelry review, I tried five different pieces to see how they look in person, what I thought of the quality, and where I’d realistically wear each one.
The selection gave me a pretty good mix to work with, too. I received two necklaces, a tennis bracelet, classic diamond studs, and diamond huggie earrings, with styles ranging from subtle enough for a casual outfit to pieces I’d save for a night out. My Brilliant Earth jewelry review focuses heavily on those differences because I don’t think every beautiful piece of jewelry needs to serve the same purpose in your closet.
One piece became my favorite almost immediately, while others made more sense to me for specific outfits or occasions. I’ll break down the quality, appearance, sparkle, styling possibilities, and my personal thoughts on all five pieces, including what I’d reach for again. If you’re considering buying from the brand and want a Brilliant Earth jewelry review based on actually seeing and wearing the jewelry, here’s what stood out!
Brilliant Earth Jewelry Review: I Tried 5 Pieces + My Thoughts
1. Petite Lab Diamond Tennis Bracelet
The Petite Lab Diamond Tennis Bracelet is one of the dressier pieces I tried, and I immediately pictured it with a hot outfit for a night out. The 14K yellow gold bracelet features 90 round lab grown diamonds totaling at least 1.40 carats, so there’s plenty of sparkle without the bracelet looking overly bulky. I like that the design is petite and relatively simple because the diamonds can do most of the work. This is the piece I’d choose when I wanted my jewelry to feel noticeably fancier and add some extra sparkle to an outfit.
2. Perfect 4 Prong Certified Lab Diamond Stud Earrings
These diamond studs are probably the most classic and versatile option of the five pieces. The pair I reviewed features two round lab grown diamonds totaling 1.5 carats, set in an 18K yellow gold four prong setting. They’re sparkly enough to stand out, but the simple design makes them easy to wear without having to plan an entire outfit around your earrings. I could see these working just as well with a nice everyday outfit as they would for dinner, a wedding, or another dressier occasion.
3. Hydrangea Bouquet Pendant
The Hydrangea Bouquet Pendant is cute and has a little more personality than a traditional gold pendant. Made with 14K yellow gold, the floral inspired design combines London Blue topaz, sapphire, aquamarine, and a diamond, which gives it some subtle color and detail. I think this one makes the most sense as an accessory for casual outfits when you want your necklace to add something interesting without becoming the main focus of your look.
4. Jane Goodall Leaf Lab Diamond Pendant Necklace
This was easily my favorite piece of the five. The 14K yellow gold Jane Goodall Leaf Lab Diamond Pendant Necklace has a simple leaf design accented with 21 lab grown diamonds totaling at least 0.07 carats, and the chain can be adjusted to 16, 17, or 18 inches. I love that it feels simple and cute rather than overly fancy. It’s exactly the type of necklace I’d use to enhance a casual outfit when I wanted a little sparkle without looking dressed up, which makes it one of the pieces I’d realistically reach for most often.
Related: 4 Pieces from the Brilliant Earth Jane Goodall Collection That We’re Obsessed With
5. Taylor Lab Diamond Huggie Earrings
The Taylor Lab Diamond Huggie Earrings have a really versatile appeal, and I can definitely see why they’re a favorite for so many. The 14K yellow gold pair features 14 round lab grown diamonds totaling at least 0.30 carats, with a larger diamond paired with smaller diamonds along each hoop. The diamonds are quite sparkly, and I think these work best as a fashion statement where less is more. They’re small enough that they don’t overwhelm your look, but there’s still enough sparkle to draw attention to them.
Brilliant Earth Jewelry Review: My Honest + Final Thoughts
Don’t spend hundreds of dollars on jewelry based on product photos alone when the details that matter most often become clearer once you know how a piece actually looks and fits into someone’s wardrobe. After wearing and looking closely at all five pieces for this Brilliant Earth jewelry review, I found options I’d pair with everything from a casual daytime outfit to something much dressier for a night out.
As I mentioned earlier, my favorite was the yellow gold Jane Goodall Leaf Lab Diamond Pendant Necklace. I love how simple and cute it looks while still adding something special to an otherwise casual outfit. The tennis bracelet is where I’d turn when I wanted noticeably more sparkle, while the other necklaces and earrings each bring something different depending on your personal style. That’s one of my biggest takeaways from this Brilliant Earth jewelry review: think about where you’ll actually wear a piece, what you already own, and whether you want your jewelry to quietly complement an outfit or become part of the statement.
Take a closer look at the pieces that fit the way you dress before deciding which one deserves a place in your jewelry collection. Based on the five pieces I received, Brilliant Earth offers everything from understated everyday designs to sparkling diamond jewelry that can completely change the feel of an outfit. Hopefully, this Brilliant Earth jewelry review makes it easier to picture how these pieces might look beyond the product page and decide which style feels most like you!
